Earlier this week, the current HHS Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., took aim against autistic people with high support needs—people like my adult son, claiming with unapologetic eugenic fervor that “Autism destroys families, but more importantly it destroys our greatest resource which is our children. And these are kids who will never pay taxes, they’ll never hold a job, they’ll never play baseball, they’ll never write a poem. They’ll never go out on a date.”
I was infuriated, not least of all because this statement came on the heels of his disturbingly pseudoscientific claim that he would find the cause of autism in five months, but also because so much of the work we do here at TPGA is to help people understand that all autistic people have inherent worth and value purely by existing, that they are loved, that they deserve any supports they may need, and that so many of the roadblocks to autistic people and their families living their best lives are due to lack of understanding and acceptance, not because of autism itself:
I see RFK Jr. has gone full “useless eaters” about autistic people. This odious concept, that everyone has to contribute to society and not be a burden to others, is drawn straight from the Nazi eugenics playbook.
My autistic son will never work. He matters. We love him. He deserves a good life.
— Shannon Rosa (@shannonrosa.bsky.social) April 16, 2025 at 5:40 PM
RFK Jr.’s statements were so fundamentally wrong and hateful that they succeeded in doing what many in our community would have deemed impossible: Catalyzing the Autistic Self Advocacy Network and Autism Speaks (and many other orgs) to issue a Joint Statement on Upholding Scientific Integrity and Supporting the Autism Community:
“We are deeply concerned by growing public rhetoric and policy decisions that challenge these shared principles. Claims that Autism is “preventable” is not supported by scientific consensus and perpetuate stigma. Language framing Autism as a “chronic disease,” a “childhood disease” or “epidemic” distorts public understanding and undermines respect for Autistic people.”
But of course, one segment of the autism community was overjoyed by RFK Jr.’s comments: The Profound Autism Parents, or, as I call them, the Autism Grievance Parents. These parents are notable for their toxic combination of resentment over having disabled children and fury at anyone who dares to question the vile ways they publicly speak about those disabled children (especially if those critics are themselves autistic or disabled). They think RFK Jr. has their back, which means that both he and they are united in making autistic people’s lives even harder and more stigmatized than they already are.
So let’s talk about these parents, their self-defeating take on what autism means to them, and why they are so woefully misguided. This article was originally written in 2021, but as with many of our classic articles, I’ve had to update it because of this era of mega-platformed resurgent hateful ignorance.
It’s not surprising that certain parents of high-support autistic people are seeking to segregate their own children via the label “profound autism.” Parents of high-support autistics—parents like me—often aren’t given good information on how to support our autistic children who have speech or intellectual disabilities along with their autism.
Parents like me may also feel isolated when autistic kids of all support needs get lumped together with our high-support offspring, as when your child’s disabilities are really obvious, it can be hard to recognize that they share autistic traits like a need for consistency and sensory sensitivities with children whose support needs are less obvious.
We parents may then find ourselves getting frustrated by the general autism community because it includes and is led by people we perceive* as having lower support needs than our own children. We might falsely believe that inclusive autism spaces can’t possibly serve our families. We might believe that a label like “profound autism” will help our children, and our families. But this approach is misguided, and you need to understand why.
When parents like me believe “profound” autism is a separate condition from “high functioning autism,” our own children’s illnesses, or common co-occurring conditions like migraines or Tourettes or anxiety can get overlooked, unaddressed, or written off as “behavior” or just “severe autism.” Such parents may get frustrated when approaches like Applied Behavioral Analysis, which ignores autistic needs in favor of conditioning “normal” behaviors, backfires.
And because of the relentless negativity, fearmongering, and pseudoscience that seeps into media coverage of autism, “profound” autism communities are also often magnets for parents whose goal is to cure or treat autism, instead of understanding how to support an autistic child—especially if that child has other disabilities. And then when “nothing worked” because all of those parents’ kids are “still autistic,” and everyone is angry and feeling hopeless, the parents are left claiming that “no one” is addressing their “profoundly autistic” children’s support needs, so they need to create a separate category.
But if the parents of “profound” autistic kids would connect with all the communities that include their kids, like the disability and communication communities in addition to inclusive autism communities, they’d be so much better off. The non-autism disability communities, specifically, tend to be more oriented towards problem-solving for their kids’ rights and accommodations and medical needs. They get equally angry about the lack of support resources because there IS a lack of support resources. But they also tend to view adults who share their children’s disabilities, and the value of their shared, lived experiences as the valuable resources they are, instead of rejecting crucial allies and supports.
Why is it so hard for parents of autistic children to understand which resources they need? One roadblock is a society that tends to view autism and disability as scary bad things, and see disabled people like our children as burdens. In addition, most mainstream autism resources were developed by professionals who haven’t gotten over the idea that disability is bad, or who aren’t part of the autistic or disability community, and who didn’t consult autistic people—so those resources tend to center on how to make autistic people easier for non-autistic people to live with, instead of focusing on autistic people’s happiness and well-being. And since a family is usually only as happy as its least happy member, and since most families are not given information about helping autistic people be happy, this means too many families with autistic members are not happy ones.
Parents who aren’t themselves autistic or disabled and who rely on these mainstream autism resources may therefore have no guidance for viewing their children positively. They may not see their kids as who they are, but rather as what they aren’t. They won’t have the lived context to teach their children self-acceptance or self-advocacy, which means their kids may not learn that they deserve and have the right to whatever accommodations they need. Again, these will not be happy families.
But if parents get their information about parenting autistic kids from the autistic community, they will find people who think that their kids are awesome, and deserve to be happy, and want their parents to feel the same way. The parents will learn about autism from people who had autistic childhoods. They can find out that the way their autistic child socializes is perfectly normal—for an autistic person—and that many social communication difficulties go both ways. They find out that the child’s strong interests can bring them deep joy, their repetitive movements can bring them peace, and their insistence on sameness can help them cope with an unpredictable world. They find out that things that non-autistic people consider “no big deal” are actually a very big deal for autistic people, like noises and flickering lights and consistency and processing delays and surprises. They learn to respect and work with the autistic child’s communication style, especially if the child uses echolalia, scripting, or alternative communication methods like typing or iPad apps. They will find out that autistic people consider ABA therapy a form of torture, and that at the same time some types of speech therapy and occupational therapy can be crucial.
When parents get information about their kids’ disabilities from the disability community, they will find people who think that their kids are awesome, and want their parents to feel the same way. They can also help parents understand that meaningful inclusion in school matters more than token mainstreaming without supports, that interdependence and being able to make choices matter more than becoming completely independent, and that being part of a community means increased personal safety while segregated living means increased personal peril.
If parents rely purely on the “profound” autism community, they are unlikely to find the resources their children need. So we need to spread the word that parents can get additional guidance from disability-centric organizations that also welcome autistic people, like Little Lobbyists, which focuses on children with complex medical disabilities; The ARC, which focuses on people with intellectual and developmental disabilities, or CommunicationFirst, which focuses on people with communication disabilities—in addition to autistic-led orgs like The Autistic Self-Advocacy Network, which advocates for autistic people of all abilities, and your autistic and non-autistic friends here at TPGA—all parents of high-support autistic children who are now taller than their mothers.
When parents find actually useful resources, the families and their children can be much happier. This doesn’t guarantee that everything will be fixed! But that is because our society does not yet provide the benefits and resources to support autistic children and families properly, and also because parenting is hard, and because all children have the potential to require more supports than their parents had ever imagined—regardless of whether they are disabled.
*Every autistic person qualifies as disabled, so every autistic person needs some kind of support and accommodations—and this is true even if a person is able to talk, go to a mainstream school, or work in a regular job.
